Should I Replace My 20-Year-Old Electric Water Heater <br> at the Same Time as My Failed Gas One?

In most cases, yes. Electric water heaters typically last 10 to 15 years, so a 20-year-old unit is living on borrowed time. Replacing both at once saves you a second service visit, lets you plan the install, and helps you avoid a second sudden failure and water-damage cleanup.

A homeowner in Reston, VA recently called us after their gas water heater failed and drained out. They had a second, older electric unit upstairs that still worked, and they wanted to know if it made sense to deal with both now.

It's a smart question. At B.L. James & Son, we see this situation often, and the answer depends on age, condition, and what you want from your hot water system going forward.

How long does an electric water heater actually last?

Most electric tank water heaters last about 10 to 15 years. A unit past 20 has outlived its expected life, even if it still makes hot water today.

Age matters because the inside of the tank slowly corrodes. Sediment builds up, the anode rod wears out, and the steel tank eventually develops a leak. When that happens, it rarely gives much warning.

What are the signs an old water heater is about to fail?

The most common warning signs are rust-colored water, rumbling or popping noises, moisture around the base, and water that never gets as hot as it used to. Not every failing heater shows these signs, though.

-Rusty or cloudy hot water

-Popping or rumbling sounds from sediment buildup

-Small puddles or dampness near the tank

-Running out of hot water faster than before

-Visible corrosion on fittings or the tank itself

If a unit is past 20 years old, we don't wait for symptoms. A professional water heater servicing visit can tell you how much life is realistically left.

Is it worth replacing both water heaters at the same time?

Usually it is, especially when one unit has already failed and the other is well past its expected lifespan. Doing both together comes with a few clear advantages.

-One planned project instead of two separate disruptions

-No surprise leak from the older unit later on

-Matching equipment choices, so you can plan your whole hot water setup

-Less risk of water damage to finished spaces, especially upstairs

That upstairs location is worth thinking about. A tank leak on an upper floor can damage ceilings and floors below, which costs far more than the water heater itself.

Should I switch from gas to electric or go tankless in Reston, VA?

It depends on your household's hot water demand, your home's existing gas, electrical, and venting setup, and your long-term goals. There's no single right answer for every Reston home.

Tankless units heat water on demand and take up less space, but they have different installation requirements. Electric models can simplify venting, though your electrical panel has to support them. Tank replacements are often the most straightforward swap.

A technician can look at your current gas line, venting, electrical capacity, and hot water use, then lay out your options. The cost depends on the size and type of system and the scope of the work, so we give you a current quote after seeing your setup.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I wait to replace my second water heater until it fails?

You can, but it's a gamble. A water heater past 20 years old can fail at any time, and the failure often means a flooded floor. Replacing it on your schedule is usually less stressful and less expensive than an emergency.

Is a water heater inspection worth it before deciding?

Yes. An inspection checks the tank condition, valves, venting, and connections so you know what you're dealing with. You can learn more about our plumbing and water heater inspection service.

Who will be doing the work on my water heater?

Our licensed team has served homeowners in the area for years. You can read about our experience and background on our about page.

Ready to sort out your water heaters in Reston, VA?

If you have a failed unit, an aging one, or both, we can take a look and walk you through your options. Contact us today to talk with our team about your Reston, VA home, and we'll share current availability and a quote for the work.

‍

Call B.L. James & Son

The B.L. James & Son team likes to move quick and reply to customer inquiries the same business day. Once we troubleshoot the issue, estimates are provided the same day or by the end of the next day. Our work begins the moment you call. Our office is open Monday–Friday, 8:30 AM–4:30 PM, with emergency services available. Call B.L. James & Son, we’ll be there to help.

Download Our New Services Brochure

Email has an ability many channels don’t:
creating valuable, personal touches – at scale

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.